A CONTROVERSIAL scheme to build 145 flats in Skeldergate, York, would enhance the Bishophill area of the city, a Government inspector heard.

Residents and conservationists have voiced major opposition to the scheme, which would lead to construction of a five-storey block of flats on the site of the NCP car park. City of York Council planners eventually rejected it.

But developer Bryant Homes lodged an appeal against their decision. Planning inspector Alan Novitsky yesterday heard town planner and Bryant Homes' witness Iain Bath argue that the scheme would enhance the area.

"It is considered that the replacement scheme will lead specifically to the enhancement of the character and appearance of the conservation area in this location," he said.

"The appeal proposals are of an appropriate height, scale and mass, recognising local characteristics." He said the neighbouring Varvills warehouse, which is also being developed for residential use, was also five-storeys high.

The inspector earlier heard from the council's conservation architect, Janine Riley, who claimed the proposed building was too dense and was "bland." He has also heard objections from Bishophill residents and from representatives of city conservation groups.

The inquiry was expected to end today.

Updated: 12:19 Thursday, November 14, 2002