North Yorkshire Police today suffered another scathing attack as its low morale, secrecy and lack of commitment to women were condemned by Government watchdogs.

In a stern report published by her Majesty's Inspector of Constabulary, urgent calls are made for a radical shake-up to disperse the clouds hanging over the force in the wake of recent scandals.

It highlights the two-year investigation into the North Yorkshire force's handling of sexual harassment claims which led to a six-figure pay-out to Harrogate police officer Libby Ashurst and the controversial departure of former chief constable David Burke.

The report says North Yorkshire Police is at a "cross-roads" and in need of a complete "root and branch review" with problems rife throughout its management.

Today's report blames lack of openness for a breakdown in employee communications and attacks the "disappointing" attitudes towards women which still prevail months after the Libby Ashurst scandal.

The report says: "Without significant investment in the human resource strategy, it is unclear as to whether the force could support a meaningful change to its organisational culture.

"Nowhere is this more required than in the area of equal opportunities, yet the Inspector was disappointed to find little evidence of commitment let alone investment.

"There is a clear and unequivocal under-representation of female officers in ranks above constable and in special posts."

Harrogate MP Phil Willis said: "It vindicates the campaign I have been waging over the past few years.

"It is an appalling indictment of the police that the inspectors visiting in February 1998 - months after the scandals - found little evidence of investment or commitment towards women. I think that speaks volumes."

Despite the criticism, the report - which also lavishes praise on the Force for its spirit among officers, falling crime levels and effective use of Special Constabulary - has been welcomed by new chief constable David Kenworthy.Mr Kenworthy said the report reflected many of his own views. He said: "I am clear about the direction in which I want to take this force and it is fortunate that this thorough inspection was conducted as I took up the reins in North Yorkshire.''

Ryedale MP John Greenway, shadow spokesman for home affairs, said: "The force is doing well operationally, which is a credit to police officers. But there is no doubt the police service is undergoing a change of managerial style."

David Burke was not available for comment today.

See COMMENT: Time for police to look ahead

Converted for the new archive on 30 June 2000. Some images and formatting may have been lost in the conversion.